pleeplydocs

Compare

Private alternatives to Alexa

Updated 3 min read View .md

If you want a voice assistant that doesn't send your voice to Amazon, the main options are Home Assistant's Assist with local speech and an Ollama model, an open-source assistant such as OpenVoiceOS, a DIY Raspberry Pi build, or a device that runs its AI on board. Each trades some convenience for privacy.

Comparison#

OptionWhere your voice is processedUp frontOngoingEffort
Amazon Alexa+Amazon's cloudAn Echo device$19.99 a month, or included with PrimeLowest
Google speaker with GeminiGoogle's cloudA Google speakerPaid Gemini plan after a trial, reportedly about $10 a monthLow
Home Assistant Voice PE + local AIYour own servers$59 plus a server for Home Assistant and OllamaNoneMedium to high
OpenVoiceOSYour deviceA Raspberry Pi, microphones and a speakerNoneHigh
DIY Raspberry Pi (Whisper + Ollama + Piper)Your deviceA Raspberry Pi 5, microphones and a speakerNoneHigh
pleeply (in development)On the speakerExpected $299 (One), $549 (Pro) or $499 (Pocket prototype)Not announcedLow (planned)

How to choose#

  • You want it to just work: a cloud speaker is the easiest, but your requests are processed by the provider.
  • You already run Home Assistant: add the Voice Preview Edition and the Ollama integration — the strongest local option today. See Use a local LLM with Home Assistant.
  • You like building things: a Raspberry Pi 5 with Whisper, a 1–3B model and Piper. See Run an LLM on a Raspberry Pi 5.
  • You want local AI without assembling it: a device built for it, such as pleeply.

What you give up by going local#

  • Small local models are less capable than Alexa+'s cloud models on complex questions.
  • Fewer ready-made integrations, such as shopping and some music services, and setup takes time.
  • Smart-home control runs through your own hub rather than Amazon's ecosystem.

FAQ#

Is there an Alexa alternative that works offline?#

Yes. Home Assistant's Assist can run fully offline with local Whisper, Piper and an Ollama model, and so can a DIY build on a Raspberry Pi 5. An Echo stops working without internet.

Is there an Alexa alternative without a subscription?#

Local setups have none: Home Assistant, OpenVoiceOS and DIY Raspberry Pi assistants are free software, and you pay only for hardware. Alexa+ costs $19.99 a month unless you have Prime.

What is the most private smart speaker?#

One that processes speech and runs its language model locally, so audio never leaves your home. Today that means Home Assistant's Voice Preview Edition with local processing, or a DIY build.

Can I use Alexa with Home Assistant and stay private?#

You can use an Echo as a front end for Home Assistant, but your voice requests are still processed by Amazon. For privacy, use Home Assistant's own Assist with local speech processing.

Sources#

Want this without building a server?

pleeply is an early project: a speaker with a built-in computer that runs open models at home. There's no prototype yet, and your answers decide what we build first.

Answer 5 quick questions →30 seconds · only email is required · no payment

pleeply Community

Keep going with the community

Running AI at home is easier with people who've already done it. On the pleeply forum you can:

  • ask about local models, hardware and Home Assistant, and get answers from people running them;
  • vote on what pleeply should do first;
  • show your own local-AI setup and get feedback;
  • hear first about test builds and reservations.

Free · no email needed

This page is also available as Markdown. For the full docs index, see llms.txt.